"It should have been me." Gabie is shocked when her coworker Kayla vanishes one night while performing a routine pizza delivery. However, her fear intensifies when Gabie discovers that the man who ordered the pizzas asked if she was on delivery duty that night. So begins The Night She Disappeared by April Henry.
Kayla’s abandoned car is found along an isolated road. Nearby, a bloody rock is discovered beside the river. Many people in the community, including the police, believe Kayla is dead. Her family even brings in a psychic who agrees with this conclusion. Only Gabie seems to believe Kayla is still alive and she becomes obsessed with proving this is true. She finds assistance with this task, and some much needed companionship, from another Pete’s Pizza employee named Drew. Drew took the pizza order that led to Kayla’s disappearance, and being unable to help the police with any details about the caller’s identity, struggles with feelings of guilt and helplessness.
The story is told from multiple different perspectives: Kayla, Gabie, Drew, and "John Robertson", the alias used by the abductor. The reader experiences each day of the kidnapping from these character’s viewpoints, and with each passing day, the terror builds. Gabie’s anxiety grows as she becomes more convinced that she is targeted to be the mysterious kidnapper’s next victim. Kayla is certain her time is running out. John Robertson is preparing to make his next move.
Will Gabie be grabbed next? What will happen to Kayla? Can John Robertson be stopped before he completes his evil plans? Read this exciting novel, and find out!